I know you said you wanted to know about other makes - but here is my independent review of the Nobile.
Kiteboard review – Nobile Skim 130 x 50.5
Wind 12-16kts cross-onshore chop
Tester’s weight 72kg
Short review:-
Strapless riding with a skim is definitely fun. Something new to learn with kiting. Simple to get going, yet would take many hours of riding to master. Can be ridden forwards and backwards with ease. Specifically designed by kiters for kiters. A wonderful fun toy but a little pricey.
Light wind capabilities – unfortunately not tested on this occasion, as it was blowing all the time I had the board! Will have to try it again in the light stuff and post an update.
Long review:-
This is the first kite specific skimboard I have ridden. I tested it with the four fins attached. What is evident straight away is the design was made by a kiter. The board is light with good footgrip pads and a grabrail around the nose. The shape of a skimboard has been adapted with kiting in mind – it has thin extended rails.
The skimboard looks well built, but not as strong as some kiteboards, it is light remember. I would not say that it is going to be as bombproof as your kiteboard if you start hitting rocks or coral in the shallows. The following comes from Mr. Shinn himself “The construction is for sure less expensive than our twin tips…..The core is in fact Airex because these boards can be placed under extreme stress. The moulding process is the same as is used in normal twin tips but instead of ABS sidewalls is built using a CAP technology.”
Footgrip pad positioning is good enabling you to keep your feet on the soft sticky stuff whether you are riding nose or tail forward.
Riding backwards – I was initially concerned that the shape of the board would make this difficult but I was so wrong. For me, the first tack with the board pointing backwards felt almost better than my first tack the right way round – incredible how easy it was. If you need to get upwind then just ride the board forwards and backwards – so simple.
Riding toeside – a lot of fun – just move your feet slightly over the board and keep the tail or edge biting as you make the turn.
Gybing – possible with practice – I managed a couple of feet switches but the board is short and very specific with regards to weight distribution. I find gybing a surfboard easier but then I have more time on one of those.
Upwind – As I said the wind was blowing for the test but the amount of water the board displaces mean that you can point this board so much more upwind than a twintip. Hopefully this bodes well for some light wind riding.
Buoyancy – Perfect for kiting – It lies flat on the water enabling you to beach start with ease. If you want to water start it then as soon as you put your heels on the board, the edge just dips that little bit underwater enabling an easy feel to starting off. It has none of the over buoyancy problems you have with riding a normal surfboard. I got going on my first attempt as did another rider who has not ridden strapless with a kite before! Just shows you how well designed it is.
The board will jump, or at least hop. You just need to convince yourself your feet will stay on the board! I managed to nail hops over wave and chop faces after an hour or so of riding. It is a great feeling when you come down with the board still somehow underneath your feet and ride away. It will take ages to master half of the stuff that Mr.Shinn can do however!
So what are my negatives – well basically just the price. I understand the board has been specifically designed and built for kiters but it is still on the pricey side. If it will also work as the light wind board option for kiters then it looks better value.
For me this is a great toy to have in the car for when the wind is blowing all day and you have hours to play on the beach. As soon as you have had your fill of trick / twintip riding then get it out and have a completely different feel to kiting. Hopefully it will also perform in the light stuff, but we will have to wait and see for that test.